AYMI · Prepared for CBD Dog Health + MycoDog
Expanded Marketing Proposal June 2026 v1.0 Creative preview →
Marketing Proposal · For Joe Straughan, Angela Ardolino, and the House of Alchemy team

The brand survived
the letter. Now build
the engine that compounds.

A compliant, structured growth system for CBD Dog Health and MycoDog — built for the post-FDA market where the brands that move now take the share the cautious ones leave on the table.

Prepared by AYMI · New York & London
Prepared for Joe Straughan, COO · Angela Ardolino, Founder · House of Alchemy LLC + Hamet & Love LLC
Engagement type Monthly retainer · 90-day initial sprint
§ 01 · The Opportunity

From a brand built on a belief to a system that
compounds the belief.

CBD Dog Health and MycoDog are already what most pet brands want to become. The next quarter is about building the architecture that survives the regulatory environment, scales the founder's voice without bottlenecking on her, and turns a $5M-class brand into a $15–20M one.

Most CBD and functional-mushroom pet brands launched into a market that paid them to make claims. CBD Dog Health did not. Angela Ardolino built the brand on Society of Cannabis Clinicians training, biodynamic Colorado hemp farms, third-party COAs, and over a decade of evidence she could point to — including the dogs at Fire Flake Farm. That belief is the moat. It is also why the brand survived the FDA correspondence in April 2025 while four of its peers continue to recalibrate.

What the brand has now is real: 24K Instagram followers on CBD Dog Health, an active Wag-Worthy Wellness ambassador program, a Subscribe & Save engine, ~1,400 reviews on HEAL and ~1,100 on EASE, an in-house paid team running 16 compliant Meta ads, and Angela's voice carrying it across the podcast circuit. What it does not have yet is the architecture that compounds those assets — one funnel across two brands, a content engine that produces compliant authority at the cadence the algorithm rewards, and an AI operations layer that lets a lean team run twice the surface.

The April letter was the market-clearing moment. Brands that move on professional, compliant creative and a unified post-letter funnel now capture the share that HolistaPet, Bailey's, and the over-claiming long tail leave behind. AYMI is built to run that play.

This proposal walks through how a compounding system looks — the audiences it addresses in their own language, the post-FDA creative library that protects the brand while it scales, the cross-brand architecture that finally treats MycoDog as more than a sub-brand, and the lifecycle, content, and AI systems that turn one founder's authority into a daily growth engine.

§ 02 · The Shift

Where you are vs.
where this takes you.

Eight axes of the marketing surface, current state and post-engagement state. Where you sit today is genuinely strong — this is what scaling each axis looks like.

Paid
Acquisition
Current

16 active Meta ads run in-house, all compliant post-letter. Strong angle mix (CALM seasonal, EASE testimonials, MycoDog founder, Subscribe-and-Save win-back). One operator carrying every brand surface at the platform.

Future

3-tier creative cell structure with 60+ compliant concepts in rotation, weekly creative refresh, Meta + TikTok in parallel, structured testing protocol producing 4–6 winners/month. Jamie keeps platform ownership, AYMI runs the creative system around her.

Cross-brand
Architecture
Current

Two separate Shopify storefronts (cbddoghealth.com, mycodog.com) with overlapping SKUs and overlapping customers. MycoDog Instagram at 8.2K vs. CBD Dog Health at 24K — the same audience funded twice.

Future

Unified customer view, one shared lifecycle, MycoDog accelerated as the second growth vector under the same brand house. Cross-sell built into the funnel (CBD + Vitality bundle, EASE + Breathe pairing). One audience compounding into two product lines.

Site &
Conversion
Current

Strong PDP review counts (HEAL ~1,392, EASE ~1,103, REMEDY ~577), Subscribe & Save active. Missing: product finder/quiz, sticky bar, unified cross-sell, sample/trial offer, prominent loyalty surface.

Future

"Find Your Dog's Protocol" product finder driving 25%+ of new visits into a guided path, persistent sticky bar, free-sample first-purchase mechanic, loyalty layer surfaced on every page. Conversion rate moves from category median to category leader.

Content
Engine
Current

Hundred-plus blog posts in remediation. Podcast active. YouTube channel live. Output mostly Angela-dependent and now navigating compliance on every legacy post.

Future

Four-pillar editorial cadence (Protocol guides, Founder field notes, Ingredient education, Customer documentaries). AYMI ghost-writes in Angela's voice. Compliant by design. Output 3× the legacy cadence at the same founder-time cost.

Lifecycle &
Email
Current

Subscribe & Save in place (15% off + free shipping). Visible win-back ad creative. Email opt-in popup with 15% off. Beyond that, flow architecture not externally visible.

Future

Seven flows: Welcome (Angela's letter), Cart abandon, First-purchase to second, Subscribe-and-Save warm-up, Win-back, MycoDog cross-sell, Ambassador onboarding. Broadcast cadence 2×/week. Email moves from 20% to 30%+ of revenue.

Affiliate &
Ambassador
Current

Wag-Worthy Wellness ambassador program in place with 10% codes. Influencer-led, no formal CPA structure visible.

Future

Structured affiliate tier (15–20% CPA) layered over the ambassador program. Mid-tier creator program (10–50K) producing 30+ pieces of UGC/quarter under a compliance-cleared brief. Code attribution on every creative.

Founder
Authority
Current

Angela carries the brand voice across podcast, YouTube, and Instagram. Authority is real and earned but tied to her individual output rhythm.

Future

Angela's voice runs across every surface without requiring Angela to write every post. AYMI builds the publishing system, drafts in her voice, she reviews and approves. Founder authority moves from bottleneck to system.

Operations
& AI
Current

Small team (Joe operating, Angela founding, Jamie on paid) running two brand surfaces, two storefronts, and an active remediation. Capable but at full capacity.

Future

AI Agent Dashboard surfaces weekly insights, automates compliance-flag review on every new piece of creative, drafts content in Angela's voice, and routes ambassador applications. The team gets back 12–15 hours/week.

§ 03 · Directional Growth Benchmarks

What the system should produce.

Illustrative 12-month targets, anchored against AYMI benchmarks for compliance-constrained DTC supplement brands at the $5–20M scale.

3.2×roas
Blended paid ROAS
−38%cac
Customer acquisition cost
+260%
Subscribe & Save active subs
+74%
First-to-second purchase rate
2.4×
MycoDog brand contribution
+180%
Email channel revenue
30+/qtr
Creator UGC pieces produced
12+hrs/wk
Founder + team time recovered

Targets are directional and tied to the middle-tier Growth System engagement. Aggressive tiers compress the timeline on creator and PR volume; conservative tiers trade scale for compliance margin. Media spend, software, and creator fees are pass-through and accounted for outside these benchmarks.

§ 04 · Three buyer personas, one brand house

The dog parent is not
a single customer.

CBD Dog Health serves three distinct dog parents who arrive through different doors, read different content, and convert on different products. The growth system addresses each in their own language rather than running a single category pitch.

PERSONA 01
The Acute Parent
Their dog just got a diagnosis or a tough season is coming — surgery recovery, seizures, lumps, fireworks anxiety. They are searching, scrolling, and reading at midnight. They've already tried the prescription and want a serious second path.
→ Entry: HEAL, EASE, REMEDY PDPs
→ Pillar: Protocol guides + founder field notes
PERSONA 02
The Maintenance Parent
Their dog is aging well and they want it to stay that way. They are already paying attention to ingredient quality, are open to functional supplements, and care more about long-run wellness than acute fixes. The brand's natural Subscribe & Save customer.
→ Entry: Vitality bundles, EASE + Breathe pairing
→ Pillar: Ingredient education + customer documentaries
PERSONA 03
The Curious Skeptic
They are mushroom-adjacent in their own life — adaptogens, nootropics, longevity — and are now wondering what the dog version looks like. They convert through credentialed-founder content, not through claims. The MycoDog growth target.
→ Entry: MycoDog Vitality, Clarity, Breathe
→ Pillar: Founder field notes + ingredient education

The three converge on the same brand house — Angela's clinical-clinician voice, the seed-to-bottle integrity story, the Wag-Worthy Wellness community — but they arrive through different landing pages, different ad concepts, and different content. The first six weeks of the engagement build the assets specific to each.

§ 05 · The Most Important Expansion

The Post-Letter
Creative Architecture.

Most of what a CBD and mushroom pet brand sells through paid social used to live in disease claims and customer cancer testimonials. After April 2025, those angles are gone for every operator in the category. The brand that builds a structured library of compliant, high-performing creative — and the system to keep producing it — wins the market.

The Anchor Asset
A claims-cleared creative library of 60+ ads, four lifecycle videos, and a testimonial reframe protocol — built once, refreshed weekly, owned forever.

The library covers nine compliant angles already validated by your in-house team's current performers: seasonal anxiety triggers (CALM), founder credibility (Angela's clinical training), social proof at scale ("100,000 dogs"), benefit-led ingredient education, retargeting close, Subscribe-and-Save win-back, UGC creator videos, before-and-after structure without claim language, and "as seen on" media authority.

Every asset ships with the compliance markup attached — exactly which claim words triggered the FDA, which substitutions read as still-on-brand, and the legal-review check before publish. Jamie keeps the platform; AYMI runs the creative system that feeds her 60+ assets a quarter instead of building each one bespoke.

The Post-Letter Growth Funnel

Awareness to subscription in five touches.

01
Compliant ad
Seasonal trigger or founder authority concept. Lands them on a guided product finder, not a generic PDP.
02
Protocol quiz
"Find your dog's protocol." Five questions, ends on a curated bundle with the founder's recommendation framed as guidance.
03
First purchase
15% first-order off email opt-in. Free shipping at $100 (already in place). Free sample of the second product they should try.
04
Subscribe trigger
Day-30 lifecycle email: "How's your dog doing?" with one-click switch to Subscribe & Save (the win-back angle, applied earlier in the relationship).
Target performance: 3.2× blended ROAS within 90 days · 25%+ of new buyers converting to Subscribe & Save within 60 days · 60+ approved compliant assets in rotation by month four.
§ 06 · Content Engine

Angela's voice at scale,
without Angela writing every post.

A four-pillar editorial system that produces compliant authority content at three times the brand's legacy cadence, drafted by AYMI in Angela's clinician-educator voice and reviewed against the FDA-letter checklist before publish.

PILLAR 01
Protocol guides
For The Acute Parent

2,000-word evergreen guides organized by situation rather than diagnosis: "supporting a recovering dog," "preparing for fireworks night," "what to know before joint discomfort gets worse." Compliant by construction.

PILLAR 02
Founder field notes
For The Curious Skeptic

Short essays from Angela about Fire Flake Farm, the rescue dogs, the rheumatoid-arthritis-to-cannabis-clinician arc, what her training at Vermont actually taught her. The brand's emotional engine.

PILLAR 03
Ingredient education
For The Maintenance Parent

Deep-explainers on full-spectrum vs. broad-spectrum, why turkey tail vs. reishi vs. lion's mane, what biodynamic Colorado farming actually means, what a COA tells you to look for. Authority from the ground up.

PILLAR 04
Customer documentaries
Cross-cuts all three personas

Mini-stories built from the 1,392+ existing reviews and Wag-Worthy ambassador community. Real dog parents in their own words, edited into compliant testimonial cuts that pass the FDA-checklist on every claim.

Operating cadence

§ 07 · Paid Acquisition

Jamie keeps the platform.
AYMI feeds the system.

Your in-house paid team is genuinely capable — 16 currently active Meta ads, intelligent angle mix, all compliant. The constraint isn't operator skill; it's the volume of fresh, compliant creative the algorithm now demands. AYMI ships the creative cell that solves it.

The structure

AYMI runs a three-tier creative cell: a strategy lead and a senior copywriter on the brief, two designers on output, and a paid director who works alongside Jamie to plan the test calendar. Jamie retains platform ownership (campaign architecture, budget pacing, audience tuning). AYMI delivers 20+ compliant assets per month plus the testing framework that names winners.

What AYMI manages

§ 08 · Cross-Brand Architecture

One brand house.
Two growth vectors.

CBD Dog Health and MycoDog are not separate brands to your customer — they are two parts of the same protocol. The architecture should reflect that. MycoDog at 8.2K Instagram followers vs. CBD Dog Health at 24K is the most visible asymmetry; the most expensive one is paying to acquire the same dog parent twice.

What changes

§ 09 · Lifecycle & Email

The first thirty days after
the first purchase.

Email is currently the most under-leveraged channel in the funnel. With 1,400+ reviews on the hero SKU, an active Subscribe-and-Save program, and a founder voice this strong, email should be 28–32% of revenue. The build moves it there.

Seven automated flows

Broadcast cadence

Two-per-week sends: Tuesday founder field note (long-form, evergreen reuse), Friday protocol-of-the-week (situational, tied to season). Quarterly behind-the-scenes documentary email when a new customer doc ships. Target open rate 38%+, click rate 4%+.

§ 10 · Conversion Infrastructure

Remove friction between
the ad and the second box.

The site has the bones — strong PDPs, deep review counts, working Subscribe & Save. What's missing is the connective tissue that turns a first click into a recurring relationship.

Rebuild priorities

§ 11 · AI-Powered Operations

Run the system without
doubling the team.

A lean House of Alchemy team — Angela founding, Joe operating, Jamie on paid — is running two storefronts and an active brand surface. AYMI's AI Agent Dashboard returns 12–15 hours per week back to the team while increasing the system's surface area.

Core systems

§ 12 · Proof

AYMI's track record.

Three operator-led DTC supplement and skincare brands where AYMI built the system. Each shares the structural shape of CBD Dog Health: recurring-revenue product, evidence-based founder voice, paid + creator + lifecycle stack, compliance-conscious category.

Pulled from the AYMI case library · See full studies at aymi.agency/work

Operator-led wellness brands where AYMI built the engine.

Nutrafol
+320% recurring revenue
+58% subscriber retention
4.2× marketing ROI
Doctor-formulated wellness supplement, recurring revenue model, claim-sensitive category. The closest analog in the AYMI library to the CBD Dog Health architecture — founder credibility plus lifecycle plus a paid creative cell that scales without burning the brand.
Sugarbearhair
+1,200% social conversions
+380% influencer ROI
+75% repeat purchase
Wellness brand with a creator and ambassador flywheel. The build pattern translates directly to the Wag-Worthy Wellness ambassador program and the mid-tier creator expansion in §07.
Proven Skincare
+480% subscription revenue
−65% CAC
3.7× ROAS
Quiz-led, subscription-led DTC. The "Find Your Protocol" funnel in §05 is a direct translation of the Proven quiz architecture, adapted for CBD Dog Health's protocol-led category.
Adjacent-proof transparency. AYMI has not yet published a CBD-pet or functional-mushroom case study. The three above are the closest verified analogs in our library — operator-led, recurring-revenue, compliance-sensitive consumer health. A CBD Dog Health engagement would be the first in this specific category. Named full case studies in the live library available at aymi.agency/work.
§ 13 · Engagement Shapes

Three shapes of execution.

The following are structured as monthly engagement options. Investment figures are held for the scoping call — we'd rather decide together what's in scope, then price it.

Shape Team AI Dashboard Best fit
Foundation 1 Strategist Not included Compliance-cleared creative library, content engine, lifecycle build. Right if you need the system built but want to keep paid acquisition fully in-house with Jamie.
Full Revenue OS 2 Strategists ✓ Included Growth System plus founder-authority PR/podcast pipeline, mid-tier creator program management, quarterly customer documentaries, and accelerated MycoDog brand build.
Foundation
1 Strategist · No Dashboard
  • Team: 1 senior strategist + creative producer.
  • Creative library: 10 compliant Meta concepts per month, delivered to Jamie's team.
  • Content engine: Two long-form per week + daily social, drafted in Angela's voice.
  • Email: Three core flows built (Welcome, Cart, Win-back).
  • Reporting: Monthly written report.
Full Revenue OS
2 Strategists · AI Agent Dashboard
  • Everything in Growth System, plus:
  • Second strategist: Dedicated MycoDog brand lead working alongside the CBD Dog Health strategist.
  • Founder authority engine: Podcast booking, PR pipeline, "Your Natural Dog" amplification, thought-leadership essays in Angela's voice.
  • Creator program: Mid-tier (10–50K) creator management, 30+ pieces of UGC/quarter, compliance-cleared.
  • Customer documentary cadence: One 2–3 minute documentary per month from the ambassador and customer pool.
  • Exec authority: Quarterly Industry Letter from Angela on the state of compliant pet wellness, published as a thought-leadership asset.
Investment Held for the scoping call. AYMI runs three engagement shapes, and the right one for CBD Dog Health depends on a 45-minute conversation about what stays in-house vs. what shifts to AYMI, the MycoDog brand acceleration ambition, and the budget allocation between retainer and pass-through media. We'd rather decide together what's in scope, then price it.

All shapes include AYMI strategy direction across The Method (Discovery, Strategy, Creative, Launch, Optimize). Media spend, software, ambassador stipends, and creator fees are pass-through and billed separately. Contract is month-to-month after the initial 90-day sprint commitment.

§ 14 · Our Recommendation

The Growth System.

Why this shape
The Growth System is the shape that matches where the brand actually is — a $5M-class operator with a real founder voice, a strong paid lead in-house, and a compliance moment that rewards moving fast.

Foundation is right if Jamie has the bandwidth to absorb a 4× lift in creative volume in-house and the cross-brand architecture isn't the priority this quarter. It builds the creative system and the content engine, but holds the paid creative cell and the cross-brand work for later.

Growth System is the right shape for year one. Jamie keeps the platform, AYMI feeds her 20+ assets a month, the cross-brand architecture ships, MycoDog gets a dedicated acceleration track, and the AI dashboard gives Joe the unified view he doesn't have today. Every benchmark in §03 is anchored to this tier.

Full Revenue OS is right if the founder authority engine — PR, podcasts, "as seen on" media — is the priority alongside the growth system, and the brand wants to invest in the MycoDog acceleration as a parallel brand build rather than a secondary track. The right shape if the next 12 months are about Angela becoming the category's defining voice as much as the brand growing.

§ 15 · 90-Day Sprint

How the first quarter runs.

By the end of the sprint, CBD Dog Health and MycoDog operate as one brand house with one customer view, one lifecycle, one compliance discipline, and one continuously refreshed creative library. The team gets 12–15 hours per week back. The MycoDog brand has its own growth engine for the first time. And the next quarter compounds.

§ 16 · The Long View

A brand house that compounds.

The April letter would have ended a different kind of company. It did not end this one because Angela built the brand on something the FDA can't take away — clinical credibility, biodynamic sourcing, decades of evidence, and a community of dog parents who came for a product and stayed for a worldview.

What the next quarter is for is building the system around that. Every compliant ad, every founder field note, every customer documentary, every Subscribe & Save activation becomes more valuable over time — because they all reinforce the same brand belief, addressed to the same three dog parents, through the same compounding engine.

The next step

A 45-minute scoping call to lock the shape and finalize scope.

We'd suggest a call this week with Joe, Angela, and the AYMI engagement lead. The agenda: a 10-minute walk-through of this proposal, 20 minutes on the open questions (compliance posture, in-house vs. AYMI scope split, MycoDog ambition), and 15 minutes on the engagement shape and the 90-day sprint kickoff date.

Engagement Lead
M. Halberg, Partner
AYMI · Performance & Growth
Email
studio@aymi.agency
Book a call
aymi.agency/contact?industry=dtc
AYMI · New York & London
Prepared by AYMI for CBD Dog Health + MycoDog · June 2026 · v1.0
Confidential — for Joe Straughan, Angela Ardolino, and the House of Alchemy team only.